(Close Window)
Topic: Is David Blaine ruining magic?
Message: Posted by: magicjack1977 (Jan 13, 2009 12:19PM)
It seems that David Blaine has cast a negative light on the art. His increasingly ridiculous stunts seem to be the act of a man desperate for attention and who will do practically anything to attain that attention.

It just feels like David Blaine has "cheapened" the art and made more of a mockery out of it rather than something for lay-persons to admire. A few of his specials were on tv back-to-back-to-back and we were watching at my aunts house over the holidays. There were about 20 or so people watching and nearly everyone regarded his magic as a joke or something to laugh at, especially his levatation stunts. I was embarassed a couple of times when they would turn to me and ask "do you do that kind of stuff?" I'll admit that he is a highly skilled magician, but his antics just seem to have taken the art of magic in the wrong direction and it is going to keep heading in that direction as long as he keeps orchestrating these publicity stunts that seem to irritate more people than they amaze.

David Blaine has created this image that a magician is a guy dressed as a hippie slacker who just took 3 valiums and also has apparent facial paralysis prohibiting them from smiling or showing any emotion other than sorrow with their face, walking up to random people on the street and begging for them to let him show them a trick. That's just not the image that the word "magician" should conjure up in peoples minds.

I don't know, it's just my opinion.
Message: Posted by: rickyhmltn (Jan 13, 2009 12:39PM)
Nah, I wouldn't say David Blaine is ruining magic. I separate his stunts from his magic specials. By that I mean his stunts are not illusions or magical in nature but more about human perseverance. Does David Blaine even really do magic anymore? I think most people regard him as more of a performer of stunts nowadays than a magician. I guess what I'm saying is and I don't mean this in a criticizing/bad way at all, but I would consider him a stuntman first who does a few magic things rather than a magician first who also does stunts.
Message: Posted by: M Sini (Jan 14, 2009 08:31AM)
I'll keep my opinion out of it and just say that after his last TV special, all I kept hearing about from lay people was the "match trick", "the one where the girl flicked to her card in the deck" and the one with the "x's on the hand."

Everyone said they didn't "get" the ending of the stunt but enjoyed the magic.
Message: Posted by: Pakar Ilusi (Jan 15, 2009 11:32AM)
I wouldn't go that far. Some do really like him though.

He does his thing, we should do ours.

Take the good, leave the bad, add your own.

Message: Posted by: Dannydoyle (Jan 15, 2009 11:42AM)
No he isn't.
Message: Posted by: Pakar Ilusi (Jan 15, 2009 12:05PM)
He's NOT doing HIS thing?

Who's thing is he doing?
Message: Posted by: critter (Jan 27, 2009 09:52AM)
Well, I guess we can't all put on a tuxedo and saw a lady in half.
Some people just HAVE to do presentations that people can RELATE to.
Darn them to heck.
Message: Posted by: Casey Magic (Jan 27, 2009 10:40AM)
All I can say is that I think most magicians hate him because they are jealous in one way or another to be honest. I think they feel that, it is not them, therefore, it could be, or should be, and somehow that is bad. Who knows...I think he's pretty good at what he does.
Message: Posted by: sickmagic (Jan 30, 2009 01:02AM)
He is working and making a living doing what he loves, if he is ruining magic he isn't ruining it for himself and his audience! So are you are you doing those things? The art of magic is changing because the times change even if we don't like it. This doesn't have anything to do with Blaine it has to do with the times. When are magicians going to wake up and realize that wearing Tuxes and glitter outfits are not in anymore? We need to learn how to except things for what they are and not what they use to be. The art itself has not changed, in fact the methods and techniques are the same that they always have been. We all have different personalities and appearances and that is something we should accept even if a magician is looking like a stoner or an old man trying to be cool and hip.

Face facts things are what they are and magic is just what it is an art form that is not in the forefront like acting and video games!
Message: Posted by: David White (Jan 30, 2009 07:08AM)
On 2009-01-15 12:42, Dannydoyle wrote:
No he isn't.

I wholeheartedly agree, David Blaine is not ruining magic in any way.

Quite the opposite actually.
Message: Posted by: critter (Jan 31, 2009 10:12AM)
I'd also like to say, what he did for the kids with the Target stunt...
If you're not familiar with this story, it was in Magic magazine a little less than two years ago I think.
Blaine had never done any endorsement deals, despite being approached many times.
Finally, when Target approached him, he said there was only one condition, that they sponsor a tour of childrens hospitals for him.
For that, he threw the stunt together in a week.
That's a heck of a good guy, and someone who would do something like that can only give magic a good name.
Message: Posted by: munkywrench (Feb 3, 2009 08:52PM)
For better or worse Mr. Blaine and Mr. Angel are taking antiquated ideas and breathing new life into them. Would you say that Houdini ruined magic by doing escapes and physical stunts? I think not. In my opinion and from observations, a lot of the magic community is afraid of change and this has always ruffled feathers. The Professor is hailed by many as revolutionizing magic and bringing it from top hats and rabbits to more intriguing effects. If we let the art get stale then the fun and creativity is lost. What is killing magic is the shoddy attempts by ameteurs who place videos on the internet that are horrible. These guys breeze throught the instructions and rush to put effects on the net only to expose the mechanis of the effect. This is the cancer that is killing magic if anything.
Message: Posted by: phaddad2 (Feb 5, 2009 06:20PM)
Blaine's style was not meant for an old fart like me,But, he has made it easier for me to book high school shows because he has made magic appeal to that age group. So, I feel he has helped all us working guys.
Pete H.