I've searched around here and can't seem to find the answer to my issue.
I do not get any email notifications from the Magic Café for subjects I replied to or created.

Strange this is that I can't seem to find an option to set it up.

Is that normal? Because it's gets really hard to keep track of replies.

Thanks in advance.

You can only receive notifications if you created the topic. I've looked through your history and you have only created one topic since you registered. When you create a topic, before submitting your post, you'll see a option under the posting window to notify you by email when a reply is posted. Click on that and then submit. If you do not do this when you first post, you cannot go back and reset it. You would have to contact one of the moderators to set it for you. Likewise, if you no longer wish to receive the notice, you would have to contact a moderator.

Okay now I understand it better.
Thank you for letting me know this.