The Magic Café
Username:
Password:
[ Lost Password ]
  [ Forgot Username ]
The Magic Cafe Forum Index » » Penny for your thoughts » » Question about Mentalism & Magic (0 Likes) Printer Friendly Version

 Go to page 1~2 [Next]
BillyTheSquid
View Profile
Veteran user
My bamboo hut's supported on
331 Posts

Profile of BillyTheSquid
Hi,

As I'm currently trying to decide which path to go down in terms of mentalism & magic and having seen various DVDs with mentalism / mental magic and plain magic on them, can anyone help me with the differences between the three? What I first considered mentalism to be seems to have become mental magic in my mind (no pun intended) from seeing how many gimmicks are employed in various routines.

Cheers,
Matt
Talizman
View Profile
New user
Peterborough, UK
33 Posts

Profile of Talizman
I would define a mentalist effect as one which simulates a supposedly real mental or parapsychological phenomena. This doesn't mean that the mentalist performing the effect need necessarily be trying to convince the audience that he or she geuniunely possesses such and such a power or ability; he or she might present the effect as a demonstration of real psychic abilities, or as the application of advanced psychological techniques, but equally he or she might simply stay silent on the matter, or might even go so far as to admit to the involvement of a certain amount of subterfuge. However, regardless of what explanation the mentalist provides (if any), a strong mentalist effect should have the ability to leave the audience, or at least a substantial portion of the audience, wondering about the true nature of what they have just witnessed.

Magic, on the other hand, lacks this potential for apparent veracity. This is not to belittle magic; when performed well, a magic effect can come across as far more than 'just a trick'. However, although a magic effect can baffle and even astonish an audience, very few people in this day and age would be willing to even consider the possibility that they have witnessed 'real' magic.

Which leads us to the difference between mentalism and mental magic. An example of a mentalist effect would be to divine the identity of a playing card that a spectator is merely thinking of. Mental magic, however, would incorporate some magical element, such as a card not only being divined, but being made to disappear from the deck and materialise in the spectator's jacket pocket.
“A Thaum is the basic unit of magical strength. It has been universally established as the amount of magic needed to create one small white pigeon or three normal-sized billiard balls” - Terry Pratchett
IAIN
View Profile
Eternal Order
england
18816 Posts

Profile of IAIN
For me, a lot of magic is based purely on the visual, with occasional storylines to help explain the visual side of the story...its an external process...

mentalism is an internal process for the main part,the reaction is inside the mind, the shock, the reading of a thought, whatever is being displayed...

mental-magic is a visual thing, but with a kind of alluding to mind-reading via the visual element...that probably makes little sense really...its a thorny issue the mental-magic and mentalism for some...

don't get confused with cards either, for some they are merely tools to peform experiments with, others they are sacriligious to use with mentalism..your choice, your label...

online visions has some articles about these very subjects...
I've asked to be banned
Logan Five
View Profile
Inner circle
Northern California
1477 Posts

Profile of Logan Five
Hi Matt!

Welcome to the Café. If you look at the upper-right part of the page you'll see the " search " button. There is much wisdom that can be found when you use the " search " button.

j109~
Self concept is destiny..
Philosophry
View Profile
Veteran user
321 Posts

Profile of Philosophry
I don't agree with this definition 100% but there are some interesting ideas

What is the difference between mental magic & mentalism]
Virungan
View Profile
Inner circle
Here and There
1156 Posts

Profile of Virungan
I'm more interested in how Billy the Squid has "0 posts" including the one above...

:confused:

Did he use a NW for that post?

:)
Smile When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth...Smile
Slim King
View Profile
Eternal Order
Orlando
17675 Posts

Profile of Slim King
Must have...He's got four posts Smile
Cheers for the squid
:cheers:
THE MAN THE SKEPTICS REFUSE TO TEST FOR ONE MILLION DOLLARS.. The Worlds Foremost Authority on Houdini's Life after Death.....
Dannydoyle
View Profile
Eternal Order
20615 Posts

Profile of Dannydoyle
The big thing to remember is that these are distinctions without a difference.

One of the best "mentalists" on this board (you know who you are!) does not even call himself such a thing.

The real important thing is how you are recieved by the audience. 9 out of 10 people are going to refer to you as a magician no matter WHAT you call yourself. To PEOPLE there is little if any appreciable difference.
Danny Doyle
<BR>Semper Occultus
<BR>In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act....George Orwell
mindpunisher
View Profile
Inner circle
6132 Posts

Profile of mindpunisher
Actually I disagree. If you do a good show people will think you are real. Infact I once stopped a friend's watch in a bar once. I a girl noticed what I was doing and immediately removed the watch from her boyfriend's wrist asking me to stop it.

After she said "she hated magicians but loved all this mind stuff".

That isn't an isolated case. Just about everytine I perform an effect or occasional show the vast majority think what they saw was real.

Mentalism is different from magic. It is percieved differently and has a diferent emotional hook. Even with a disclaimer.

And that's how it should be.
eSamuels
View Profile
Inner circle
3095 Posts

Profile of eSamuels
It would have really been effective if you had stopped her boyfriend's watch..THEN made him disappear!
human
View Profile
Loyal user
297 Posts

Profile of human
Quote:
On 2007-08-14 16:56, Virungan wrote:
I'm more interested in how Billy the Squid has "0 posts" including the one above...

:confused:

Did he use a NW for that post?

:)


It's magic I tell you.
Dannydoyle
View Profile
Eternal Order
20615 Posts

Profile of Dannydoyle
Quote:
On 2007-08-14 19:04, mindpunisher wrote:
Actually I disagree. If you do a good show people will think you are real. Infact I once stopped a friend's watch in a bar once. I a girl noticed what I was doing and immediately removed the watch from her boyfriend's wrist asking me to stop it.

After she said "she hated magicians but loved all this mind stuff".

That isn't an isolated case. Just about everytine I perform an effect or occasional show the vast majority think what they saw was real.

Mentalism is different from magic. It is percieved differently and has a diferent emotional hook. Even with a disclaimer.

And that's how it should be.


I have had the same thing happen after doing close up magic in restaurants. I guess the key is if you touch them as performer. NOT the medium you choose to use.

Mentalism is percieved differently by MENTALISTS, not by people as a rule. How many people think Blaine has powers, Copperfield, Henning and so forth. Sorry but the point is not valid as it happens to ALL good magicians. (well Blaine too LOL)
Danny Doyle
<BR>Semper Occultus
<BR>In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act....George Orwell
Dr. Eamon
View Profile
Inner circle
--------eXtrementalism--------......IT'S ALL IN YOUR MIND.....
1284 Posts

Profile of Dr. Eamon
It's the way your perform it...
Dynamike
View Profile
Eternal Order
FullTimer
24111 Posts

Profile of Dynamike
Let us continue this old meeting.

Quote:
On 2007-08-14 19:04, mindpunisher wrote:
Mentalism is different from magic. It is percieved differently and has a diferent emotional hook. Even with a disclaimer.

I agree.
BillyTheSquid
View Profile
Veteran user
My bamboo hut's supported on
331 Posts

Profile of BillyTheSquid
Woah - a 2 year old dead thread resurrected!

I remember asking this way back and in the past two years of being involved in the field, have learned lots, listened lots, jettisoned lots and collected lots of information (and not a few effects - mostly using antiques I've aquired).

Since then, I've wandered down a few roads before settling on the following:
On stage - a mentalist - fuelled by Corinda, Anneman, Osterlind, Maven et al.
Close-up, a storyteller with bizarre elements, fuelled by Burger, Chelman, Punx, Borodin, Strange et al.

I've decided that, no matter how dirty the mechanics of the effect are to ME, what counts is the effect that the audience perceives. Is it clear, concise, powerful and not easily explained away, ie, a mystery? If not, why am I wasting their time? I want the minimum of sleights / gimmicks etc in order to concentrate on the story / audience control / build-up and getting the audience to engage with a willing suspension of disbelief, so will spend time working out reducing slights / easing them. In a rationalistic world, I have realised that there's still a thirst in people for a sense of awe and wonder.

Gone are the early days when I thought magic / mentalism was just about giving the audience puzzles or tricks. I've realised just how much of an artform it is, and that many magicians / mentalists seem to have not realised this and are just out there to show off and play the "being a god" role without taking people on the journey with them.

I have to agree that mentalism really is a form of "entertainment for adults" (now I realise that sounds slightly dodgy, but I hope you understand what I mean Smile ). Bizzare / storytelling magic seems to concentrate more on the artform side of things (not always, but mostly from what I've seen so far). A fusion of the two - now that's what I believe can be a really, really powerful art.

Currently I'm working through Ken Weber's Maximum Entertainment. If you haven't read this - just do it! You'll quickly bypass many mistakes others make and be able to analyse your own act / routines from a completely different perspective - one that matters.

My advice (for what it's worth after only 2 years in the art) to anyone starting off in this field is:
1) Get some solid book reading behind you. Don't underestimate the power of a good book! Smile
2) Don't believe all the blurb that a dealer will tell you, check out reviews before parting with cash (esp in these £££ / $$$ tight days). All that glitters is most definitely not gold - there's plenty of rubbish out there nicely packaged and attempting to part the unwary newbie from their money.
3) Don't be afraid to cull a routine if it doesn't fit in with your style / act.
4) Don't get carried along with all the hype about conventions - some of them can be detrimental to your wallet and / or style. That said - I'm looking forward to Tabular Mentis VI this coming Saturday - WOO HOO!!!!
5) You don't know it all, no-one does.
6) Be quick to listen and try to understand. Be slow to speak and criticise - unless it's constructively.
7) When on a forum like this, it's easy to throw mud, but remember, the more mud you throw, the less ground you have to stand on each time.

Well, that's me two years on. Looking forward to the next couple and what awaits me there.

Cheers Smile ,
Matt
Dynamike
View Profile
Eternal Order
FullTimer
24111 Posts

Profile of Dynamike
So, Matt, do you see how magic and mentalism are two different types of entertainment?
BillyTheSquid
View Profile
Veteran user
My bamboo hut's supported on
331 Posts

Profile of BillyTheSquid
Yep. I do think the two can be mixed on certain occasions however.

Cheers,
Matt
Dynamike
View Profile
Eternal Order
FullTimer
24111 Posts

Profile of Dynamike
I am glad you learned something. We are here to help you.
Domino Magic
View Profile
Special user
999 Posts

Profile of Domino Magic
Quote:
On 2009-11-19 18:05, BillyTheSquid wrote:
Yep. I do think the two can be mixed on certain occasions however.

Cheers,
Matt


Matt,

You're absolutely correct, they can. Dunninger did it. Koran did it. Osterlind does it Derren Brown does it and so does Kreskin. I can't think of better examples than those giants! If you put as much importance on the magic effect(s) you include as you do your mentalism effects, you will get an outstanding reaction. I guarantee you that if you add a bit of magic to your mentalism show it will not diminish you as a mentalist. Remember, you goal is to provide entertainment.
kevin carmean
View Profile
Regular user
158 Posts

Profile of kevin carmean
I use to think any kind of magic in a mentalism show was a big mistake. I have come to find out that the audience (for the most part) can be sold anything if presented correctly.

Kevin
The Magic Cafe Forum Index » » Penny for your thoughts » » Question about Mentalism & Magic (0 Likes)
 Go to page 1~2 [Next]
[ Top of Page ]
All content & postings Copyright © 2001-2021 Steve Brooks. All Rights Reserved.
This page was created in 0.32 seconds requiring 5 database queries.
The views and comments expressed on The Magic Café
are not necessarily those of The Magic Café, Steve Brooks, or Steve Brooks Magic.
> Privacy Statement <

ROTFL Billions and billions served! ROTFL